The Cabbage Soup Diet: Does It Pass the Test?

The Cabbage Soup Diet: Does It Pass the Test?

When the only positive thing that experts have to say about the cabbage soup diet is that it encourages people to eat more vegetables, it is clear that this diet is one with more than a few short coming.

This restricted food, restricted calorie diet consists primarily of a bottomless bowl of cabbage soup, select vegetables and fruits, and large quantities of protein in the form of lean meat or poultry on select days. The duration of the diet is a rigid seven days.

Since the cabbage soup diet is lacking in both variety and complete nutrition, this seven days is long enough to lose the promised 10-15 pounds. This diet typically restricts calories to 1200 per day or less, placing this in the VLCD (very low calorie diet) range and the strong recommendation that you seek a doctor’s approval before starting this diet.

A good multivitamin can help you get the nutrients you need while on this diet, but from the aspect of calories you may not have the energy to do much. Light-headedness and fatigue with an inability to concentrate are the most prominent side effects reported on the cabbage soup diet followed up with reports of bloating or excessive gas due to the nature of the cabbage and other vegetables in the soup.

The two advantages of the cabbage soup itself is that the dieter should stay well hydrated, and the fiber should prevent any feelings of hunger.

The drawback to this type of diet is that a dieter may simply choose not to eat rather than be limited to the foods allowed on a particular day. For instance, day four of the diet is marked with the cabbage soup, up to eight bananas, and as many glasses of skim milk as you like.

No other foods are listed for this day, and the purpose of this day is to eliminate cravings for the sweets.

Sadly though, deprivation diets such as this can actually trigger their reverse and lead to binging. If the dieter has the willpower to stay on the cabbage soup diet for seven days then they must also maintain their willpower not to indulge when their eating is no longer restricted.

Cabbage soup has not been shown to reduce fat any more or less than any other vegetable in its family. It is a healthy, low-carbohydrate, high-fiber vegetable good to incorporate into any diet, as are the onions, celery and other vegetables to be found in the soup.

What’s not good are the excess levels of salt and MSG that plague most recipes for cabbage soup. High sodium diets have been linked to high blood pressure and while this diet lasts only a week, experts caution the dangers of too much salt.

Because the diet is lacking in protein as well there is a real danger of losing muscle mass. If the body feels starved it will break down muscle tissue for protein. Since muscle is the primary fat burner in the body, sustainable weight loss is not feasible without muscle mass.

The Cabbage Soup Diet

Even the marketers of the diet will admit to the shortcomings and recommend that the diet is followed for one week only, allowing two to three weeks between sessions on the cabbage soup diet. This diet is not practical for most people, but if you need to lose ten pounds in a week and only need to keep it off for a couple of days, then the cabbage soup diet may be your temporary solution.

Leave a Comment: